Is Your State Thriving or Floundering? The Stark Divide in America’s Economic Recovery
Find Out How Your State Stacks Up in the Latest Rankings of Economic Performance
As inflation looms and interest rates remain at historic highs, the US economy paints a complex picture. While some states are thriving, experiencing economic booms and lower unemployment, others are floundering, weighed down by poverty, stagnant wages, and sluggish growth. A new report by GoBankingRates reveals the top 15 thriving state economies and the 15 states lagging behind—and the results are both eye-opening and revealing.
This latest analysis underscores a growing economic divide between regions, with Southern states struggling the most, while parts of the West and Northeast show resilience and growth. Using key economic indicators such as unemployment rates, GDP growth, wages, and poverty levels, researchers mapped the winners and losers in the American economy today.
The Bottom 15: States Struggling to Recover
The South appears to be bearing the brunt of ongoing economic challenges, with seven states ranking among the 15 worst-performing economies:
- Louisiana
- Mississippi
- Arkansas
- Kentucky
- West Virginia
- Oklahoma
- Tennessee
Midwestern states such as Illinois, Michigan, Ohio, Iowa, and Indiana have also struggled to regain momentum, while Western states including California, New Mexico, and Oregon round out the list of underperformers.
One of the hardest-hit states is Louisiana, which has consistently ranked as one of the nation’s weakest economies in recent years. The state faces a combination of economic hurdles, from a lack of industrial diversification to repeated natural disasters.
“Louisiana hasn’t fully recovered from the pandemic, and the recurring hurricane seasons have made it nearly impossible to gain economic traction,” said Jose Bautista, an economics professor at Xavier University. Hurricanes like Ida, Laura, Delta, and Zeta have caused widespread damage, further disrupting an already struggling economy.
Other states in the South face challenges ranging from weak job markets to declining industrial bases, making recovery even more elusive.
The Top 15 Thriving Economies: A Beacon of Growth
In stark contrast, the report highlights states that are booming, thanks to economic diversity, strong job markets, and rising wages. The top 15 thriving economies include:
- Utah
- Idaho
- Virginia
- Colorado
- Washington
- Alaska
- Arizona
- DC (District of Columbia)
Utah, often referred to as the poster child for post-pandemic recovery, leads the way. Its strong and diverse economy, with sectors ranging from tech and tourism to finance and manufacturing, has made it one of the most resilient states in the nation.
“Utah’s stability before the pandemic gave it a strong foundation, and its proactive economic policies have helped it rebound more quickly,” noted an economist from the University of Utah.
States like Colorado and Washington have also benefited from their tech-driven economies and high levels of innovation, attracting both investments and workers from around the country.
Even Alaska, with its reliance on natural resources, has seen gains as global demand for energy remains high, bolstering its economy.
How the Rankings Were Determined
To evaluate each state’s economic health, the study analyzed four critical metrics:
- Unemployment rates (March 2024): A lower unemployment rate indicates a stronger job market.
- GDP growth (Q3 to Q4 of 2023): Growth in Gross Domestic Product reflects an expanding economy.
- Average weekly wages (Q1 2023): Rising wages are a key indicator of economic vitality.
- Poverty levels (2022): A lower percentage of people living below the poverty line signifies a healthier economy.
By combining these metrics, researchers were able to create a comprehensive picture of which states are thriving and which are falling behind.
Related: NYC Bans Landlord-Mandated Broker Fees: A Landmark Move for Renters Amid Real Estate Pushback
A Deepening Divide: Why Some States Struggle While Others Thrive
Economic experts say the reasons behind these disparities are complex. Southern states often face structural challenges such as higher poverty rates, limited job opportunities, and less diversified economies. Natural disasters, such as hurricanes and floods, add another layer of difficulty for many states in this region.
On the other hand, states like Utah and Colorado benefit from more robust infrastructures, diversified industries, and innovative sectors that make them less susceptible to economic downturns.
A Silver Lining on the National Level
While some states struggle, the national economy is showing signs of hope. The Dow Jones Industrial Average recently hit a milestone, surpassing the 40,000-point mark for the first time. The S&P 500 and Nasdaq also reached record highs.
Investors responded positively to news that inflation has begun to cool, with April’s annual rate at 3.4%, down from 3.5% in March. This development has sparked optimism that the Federal Reserve might begin cutting interest rates by September.
What’s Next for Interest Rates?
Currently, the Federal Reserve has kept interest rates at a 23-year high, between 5.25% and 5.5%, in an effort to combat inflation. While this policy has helped cool inflation, it has also slowed economic growth, making it harder for struggling states to recover.
Many economists predict the Fed will only cut rates if inflation continues to fall toward its target of 2%. However, some experts warned that rate cuts could be delayed if inflation remains stubbornly high.
What This Means for You
The economic divide across states shows that where you live can significantly impact your financial well-being. Thriving states offer better job opportunities, higher wages, and more economic security, while struggling states face persistent challenges that make life more difficult for residents.
As inflation continues to cool and interest rates remain high, the coming months will be critical for determining how quickly the nation—and its individual states—can return to sustained growth and stability.